After watching the best movie he has ever seen in his life, Peter (Steven Krimmel) is told of a movie sequel that he can rent exclusively on his obscure film rental service. On his way to the post-office his car breaks down with only half an hour until the post-office closes. Peter goes straight to the girl next door, Addie (Allison Collette), to ask for a car ride as she is recovering from a break-up. A romance ignites between the both of them on this odd day, but Peter's love for movies and Addie's love for her ex-boyfriend stands between them.