Her Cardboard Lover

Her Cardboard Lover, released in 1942 and directed by George Cukor, is a vibrant, comedic and heartwarming romantic film filled with a cast of talented actors. The film's leads, Norma Shearer, Robert Taylor and George Sanders blend their unique charms and acting skills to create a captivating story that continues to resonate with audiences to this day.

The movie features Norma Shearer in the crucial role of Consuelo Croyden. Shearer, a seasoned actress from the Golden Age of Hollywood and the first woman to be nominated five times for an Academy Award, delivers a sterling performance in this film. She embodies the high-spirited, vivacious, and headstrong Consuelo with grace and effortless charm.

Consuelo, an affluent socialite, has a self-confessed weakness for the suave, debonair, but ultimately elusive playboy, Tony Barling, played with charisma and aplomb by the handsome George Sanders. Sanders was an English actor, singer-songwriter, music composer, and author known for his zesty on-screen performances. In Her Cardboard Lover, he delivers just that, bringing to life the irresistible yet aloof Tony, who continually keeps Consuelo at arm's length, creating a complex, compelling romantic dynamic on-screen.

In a bid to steer clear of Tony, who has repeatedly broken her heart and yet holds an unparalleled fascination for her, Consuelo hires Terry, a witty and charming young man with a knack for words, to pretend to be her lover. The role of Terry is played with endearing warmth and charm by Robert Taylor, who was one of the most popular leading men of his time.

Terry's role may be that of a scapegoat, however, he's not about to let that define his identity. On the contrary, he takes on the challenge with gusto, utilizing this opportunity to get close to Consuelo and make her his own. His quick wit, humor, and ready repartees add spark to his character and bring in a delightful edge to the movie.

As the movie progresses, viewers are taken on an entertaining journey filled with comic elements, romantic entanglements, and dramatic twists. The humorous situation of a “pretend” lover creating real emotions forms the linchpin of the plot. Terry, who is initially just playing a role, finds himself growing genuinely fond of Consuelo, thus adding an element of sincerity in a world of pretense.

The performances are further underlined by the screenwriting skills of Jacques Théry, Donald Ogden Stewart, and S.N. Behrman. Their screenplay infuses a sense of spontaneous effervescence and quick-silver wit to the movie. To weave comedy, romance, and drama into a fabulously entertaining whole is no easy task, but the trio pulls it off spectacularly.

In the hands of director George Cukor, the film is a finely-crafted product. Renowned for his films revolving around strong and effervescent women, Cukor ensures that Her Cardboard Lover is no different. He handles the flick with a sure touch, skillfully juggling the romance, comedy, and drama elements of the tale.

The film also offers some musical breaks, which add to its overall appeal. The dance sequences are choreographed with an innovative and rhythmic flair, creating a mesmerizing aura. The costumes and sets provide a peek into the lifestyle of the high-society of the time, adding to the authenticity and visual appeal of the movie.

Her Cardboard Lover is an amusing, glitzy, and engaging glimpse into the world of love, heartache, and deception all shrouded under the guise of a romantic comedy. A must-watch for fans of classic cinema, romantic comedies, and splendid performances by some of the shining stars of the Golden Age of Hollywood, the film presents a timeless story of love, loss, and life served with a generous dollop of humor.