2by4

2by4, a subtle and gripping drama film directed by the talented Jimmy Smallhorne in 1998, is a movie about the exploration of identity, sexuality, and the human condition set against an urban blue-collar background. The narrative unravels through the experiences of its lead character, superbly portrayed by Smallhorne himself, who plunges into a journey of self-discovery and revelation.

The film primarily crisply portrays the immigrant working conditions, focusing on the dense and gritty life of the protagonist, Johnnie Maher (Smallhorne). Johnnie, an Irish immigrant, is a member of a construction crew based in New York. The crew builds and renovates homes under the watchful eye of their stern Irish boss, Tommie, effectively played by Chris O'Neill. The crew is a motley group of Irish expats and locals, who spend their days laboring and nights indulging in raucous parties filled with drugs, alcohol, and loose company.

2by4 maneuvers through the grey landscape of alienation that immigrants feel, juxtaposed with the close-knit camaraderie that binds them together in this foreign land. The lens also magnifies the treatment of the immigrant population in America, exploring both their struggle and resilience.

Johnnie leads a dual life, though not by choice. By day, he works tirelessly at the construction site, pounded by the stern reprimands of Tommie. By night, however, he stumbles into a series of gay encounters that develop his sexual identity alongside Bradley Fitts. In his quest to navigate this unfamiliar territory, he grapples with his own guilt and confusion, portrayed with an impressive delicacy by Smallhorne.

Alongside the exploration of Johnnie's sexuality is the unfolding of his traumatic past, with glimpses into seemingly repressed childhood memories that cause sleepless nights and painful flashbacks, the origins of which remain undisclosed but suggest disturbing dimensions. The narrative seamlessly integrates these moments, offering a raw and unfiltered look into the troubling history of the protagonist.

The supporting character, Tommie (Chris O'Neill), plays into the narrative subtly offering an opposition to Johnnie's double life. His hardened exterior character and the inner demons he battles echo the toxic machismo often portrayed in blue-collar scenarios.

Bradley Fitts’ character catalyzes Johnnie's journey into his sexuality, providing a character that is starkly different from the world Johnnie is accustomed to. His role introduces an intriguing contrast to the tense and masculine atmosphere of the construction site.

Director Jimmy Smallhorne, who also embodies the protagonist, does an excellent job weaving complicated themes and plot elements into this narrative to create a compelling film. Digestible yet profound, the movie portrays a day in the life of a complex protagonist, set against a raw and real-life backdrop. 2by4 navigates the issues of identity, sexuality, and past traumas in a masterly way, often showing much with very little, through potent silences and compelling visuals.

2by4, with its edgy narrative, evocative themes, and authentic depictions of the urban working class and the immigrant experience, offers a unique film viewing experience. The balance between the grim reality of the labor-intensive days and hedonistic nights forms an intriguing backdrop for the narrative. The performances of Smallhorne, O'Neill, and Fitts immerse the audience in their world, making them almost palpable.

The script brilliantly allows for implicit storytelling, showing rather than telling, which adds to the film's intensity and authenticity. Splendid cinematography, along with a combination of blue-collar grit and vulnerable humanity, makes 2by4 a cinematic offering worth cherishing. The highlight of the film is unquestionably Smallhorne's exploration of the intricacy of his character – his silent coping, tumultuous inner struggle, and the ultimate acceptance of his identity, all profoundly evoked.

In conclusion, 2by4 is a powerful and poignant tale of self-discovery and acceptance amid a grueling physical and emotional landscape. With its riveting character portrayals and compelling themes, the film leaves a lasting impression and is recommended for audiences who appreciate thought-provoking narratives and authentic performances.